Why SUWA Decided to Compromise with the Bill Barrett Corporation on the West Tavaputs Plateau

Recently, a number of SUWA supporters (and detractors) have asked us why we decided to compromise with the Bill Barrett Corporation (BBC) regarding its proposed West Tavaputs Plateau natural gas development.  You can read our press release about the agreement here.  

In short, we did it because it was the best thing for wilderness and for protecting the incomparable Desolation Canyon.  

Probably the best way to understand this is to compare side-by-side the map of BBC’s 2008 proposed full field development and the map of the company’s 2010 contracted development proposal that was ultimately approved by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM).  The first map shows extensive oil and gas development in an area proposed for wilderness designation in America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act and even BLM-designated wilderness study areas (the small grey squares are proposed well pads and the dashed orange lines are new roads; basically every well proposed northeast and southeast of the label “Peter’s Point Mesa” is within proposed wilderness).  BBC’s original development proposal would have resulted in over two hundred new well pads inside of proposed wilderness.   

The final compromise map tells a different story: no wells in the Desolation Canyon or Jack Canyon wilderness study areas, no wells on the vast majority of Horse Bench, and four new gates preventing vehicular access on ways that reach into this terrain.  

A reality not to be overlooked was that before SUWA came onto the scene (e.g. before 1985), the BLM had already issued leases inside of the Desolation Canyon and Jack Canyon wilderness study areas; in fact, those leases predate the wilderness study areas.  Furthermore, BLM had also issued—long ago—leases on the amazing Horse Bench, a key part of America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act in the upper Desolation Canyon complex.  The fact that BBC had leases in these areas changed the ground rules—the company had a legal right to some degree of development on those leases, regardless of our proposed wilderness designations.  

Of course, we were willing to fight to make things very difficult and painful for the company in developing those leases.  Indeed, as the Bush administration rushed out the door in 2008, we were successful in blocking new leasing by the federal government in this precise area.  However, we decided to engage with BBC in the hope that we could reach an outcome more favorable to wilderness protection in this area than could be accomplished through protracted legal battles.  

We think that we found just such an outcome here.  After extensive negotiations involving give and take on both sides, we were able reach an accord preventing oil and gas wells in wilderness study areas and drastically reducing the number of proposed wells on Horse Bench.  Fortunately, BBC was a willing partner.  We were unlikely to have ever achieved such significant on-the-ground gains without this agreement.  

To be clear, it is never easy to agree to new development in proposed wilderness, even if that means only a half-dozen new wells from an original proposal of hundreds.  We struggled and sweated over this agreement for months and months.  We are not in the business of saying “yes” to development in America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act.  But, in this case, the outcome for wilderness indicates that it was better to swallow a few wells on the periphery of our proposal than to lose vast chunks of wilderness-quality land to development.     

The Desolation Canyon wilderness is one of the most stunning landscapes in the lower forty-eight states. We believe that this agreement with the Bill Barrett Corporation makes wilderness designation one step closer to becoming a reality.

David Garbett, Staff Attorney
Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance

 

Comments

[preepethyl]

for http://onlinedesignershoppingbags.weebly.com/>online designer shopping http://designer-bags-sale.weebly.com/>designer bags sale , just clicks away http://cheap-fashion-handbags.weebly.com/>cheap fashion handbags for more

[preepmuriel]

I'm sure the best for you http://designerluggageforwomen.weebly.com/>designer luggage for women http://hermes-handbags-outlet.weebly.com/>hermes handbags outlet and get big save http://discount-authentic-designers.weebly.com/>discount authentic designer handbags for gift

[pletcherxms]

http://www.pascher-sac.com>sac pas cher sera basé sur le lancement sac New Bamboo de la nouvelle emergence de l'année, y compris cette année d'accueillir la marque http://www.pascher-sac.com>chanel sac 90 l'anniversaire du lancement de la série 1921, le modèle ... mais les http://www.pascher-sac.com>louis vuitton sac sacs à galvanizing guy classique One of a kind Bamboo ne peut jamais être considéré comme les tendances introduites Le classique. 9.992.011 nouveaux KRISTIN Kristin automne funk nouvelle série point forth répondre à l'automne, added un luxe de haute qualité en cuir, facts relish et corsé et délicat chiffon doux blanc. ... Nouvelle série de KRISTIN Kristin sacs à electric cable en cuir fin 7950 RMB RESPECTED de model rond: 18 302 en cuir de chèvre bien intégré zip / téléphone / multifonctions de poche. http://www.pascher-sac.com>chanel sac est une marque des Etats-Unis, nous voyons ici est la waterfall nouveau sac à out-and-out grande nouvelle et de l'hiver, vous permettant d'effectuer un profit comprehensive volume d'une variété d'articles, vous serez en mesure de trouver votre cleaning préféré. Brown Liangpi sac d'argent grande $ 495.00 $ 495.00 Liangpi toffee-nosed carré vert sac à utter en suède avec un sac en cuir verni 595,00 $ sac à main noir en cuir polygone coin. http://www.pascher-sac.com>gucci sac sacs à duct Fendi nouveau printemps et l'été 2010 fera ses débuts. J'aime les fleurs du printemps, comme la broderie modèle, donnant un sens de la scent de la vitalité du printemps, et l'apparition de simples sacs de purs végétariens, indépendamment de la couleur à sac de travail, l'école ou le shopping sont talk up à fait approprié. Fendi Fendi ... http://www.pascher-sac.com>Dolce&Gabbana sac sacs Fendi beige bleu double-point de croix-couture Fendi Fendi Peekaboo à receivable en cuir beige.